Does Mwenda/Muhoozi claim of 97% negative coverage prove bias?

Every country has news consumers—and news avoiders—who are media illiterate. OJ-UGANDA’s media literacy section exists to change that. Follow along.

š—¢š—-š—Øš—šš—”š—”š——š—” avatar

Musaazi NAMITI | Media Literacy


LISTEN IN: Two AI voices debate this article.

Newspapers in many places report bad news most of the time. In fact, in journalism, there is a familiar line: No news is good news. Another says: If it bleeds, it sells. So, if a newspaper reports mostly bad news, does it mean it is biased? Or does this tell us something else entirely?

The text below is reproduced verbatim from an NBS TV news video clip where Andrew Mwenda, a political analyst and former journalist, shares what Gen Muhoozi Kainerugaba and army chief said about the closure of the Daily Monitor and its sister broadcasters: NTV, Spark TV, KFM and Ddembe FM. Mr Mwenda is a senior member of the Patriotic League of Uganda, a political grouping Gen Kainerugaba founded.

This Media Literacy article is inspired by what Mwenda said.

[Gen Kainerugaba was briefing] the owners of NMG about a series of complaints the government has accumulated over so many years against the media company. He had a report this thick—stories they have done over the last five years that are biased, untrue. 

You remember in journalism, we have four principles: first of all, we must always be truthful and accurate, then we must also be fair and balanced. So General Kainerugaba’s aim was to show that Monitor and sister broadcaster NTV have been reporting stories during news analysis, many of which are untrue and inaccurate. And many of which are unfair and unbalanced. 

We had done a simulation of the top 100 cover stories Monitor and NTV had done each on the government. 97% had been negative. Their last 100 major stories. 97% were negative on government. On the opposition, they were 100% positive or sympathetic. So Gen Kainerugaba’s argument is that this is not journalism; this is activism. We do not have a newspaper; we have a party mouthpiece, an opposition mouthpiece. 

And all that the government of Uganda wants, he wants, is a newspaper that is fair and balanced; that is truthful and accurate. That provides context. That in reporting about the government, it is able to provide a full picture, not a one-sided picture. In reporting about the opposition, it should do the same.

The claim that 97% of the stories sampled were negative raises three pertinent questions:

  • Are the stories false?
  • Are they unfair?
  • Are they mostly negative?

Bias is when a news outlet chooses selective reporting by emphasising facts that support one side while omitting equally relevant facts that weaken it. It also arises when an outlet applies unequal scrutiny. For example, reporters and editors may apply stricter evidentiary standards to one side than another in comparable situations.

A government, an institution or an individual can receive overwhelmingly negative coverage for the simple reason that the news available to report about them is negative, but when the reporting is accurate, fair and balanced, the issue of bias does not arise. Also, the government generates more news because it wields power, controls public resources and makes decisions affecting millions of Ugandans, which does not apply to the opposition.

As Mr Mwenda said nothing about the methodology used, the statistic in question is difficult to interpret as evidence of bias.

Law vs power

If the state possesses a five-year dossier of false and defamatory reporting, as Mr Mwenda told NBS TV, the obvious question is: Why was the law not used? Why close a newsroom by executive or military power rather than seek redress in courts?

The compilation of the dossier also raises questions.

  • Who selected the ā€œtop 100 storiesā€?
  • What counted as ā€œnegativeā€?
  • Was corruption coverage, for example, automatically coded negative?
  • Were road projects, budgets, sports, health and business stories excluded?
  • Can different coders reproduce the same 97% result?

In a free and democratic country that Uganda is aspiring to be, the government should answer bad journalism with evidence and law, rather than with the power to switch off the press.

The Media Council, for example, is mandated to arbitrate disputes between the media and the state. It is not clear whether anyone from the government spoke to the Council about the Daily Monitor being biased. In fact, when OJ-UGANDA contacted the Council recently, it said it had nothing from the government to arbitrate.

The Uganda Communications also appears to have been completely sidelined, yet is responsible for taking the kind of action Gen Kainerugaba ordered.

Wafula Oguttu’s take

As Wafula Oguttu, one of the founders of the Daily Monitor and a minority shareholder in NMG-Uganda, told Baba TV: ā€œThe newspaper was not given any warning in writing. The job of taking a TV station off air is done by the UCC. The UCC writes a letter to the broadcaster after getting a complaint from a third party. And the third party must have also complained to the broadcaster.ā€

He said the last time the government closed NMG, it paid the company shs3bn in compensation for lost business. ā€œWe won the case. The government has never won any case against NMG-Uganda except the case brought by President Museveni over a story the Daily Monitor published saying he and his family were vaccinated against Covid-19 before vaccines arrived.ā€

That story was based on a news report by a US newspaper, the Wall Street Journal. The Daily Monitor paid Mr Museveni shs300m in damages, Mr Wafula said. In the interview, he hinted at the possibility of NMG suing again for lost business.

DISCLOSURE: The author of this story writes a column for the Weekend Monitor as an independent contractor.


šŸ”“ If you care about truth, credibility and understanding how journalism really works, media literacy is essential. Follow OJ-UGANDA’s media literacy section to sharpen your news sense and separate fact from fiction. Media literacy is your weapon against misinformation, manipulation and media distrust.