Does it make sense for Catholic priests not to have sex?


The church was aware of the sex abuse record of former priest John J. Geoghan, the subject of the investigation, but the archdiocese in Boston still shuttled him from parish to parish. 

Since the mid-1990s, more than 130 people had come forward with horrific childhood tales about how Mr Geoghan fondled or raped them.

Catholic priests are not supposed to have sex under any circumstances. It is their vow of celibacy. But it is a vow that has been defied by priests more times that the church’s top leadership cares to remember.

According to media reports, the scandal unfolded when several of the women discovered they were romantically involved with the same man—and nearly traded blows.

Peruvian journalist Paola Ugaz, who reviewed the Vatican’s internal probe report about the scandal, said many of the women were initially too frightened to come forward, fearing the bishop’s influence. 

The Vatican launched its inquiry after journalist Kevin Moncada of Sin Fronteras published an expose in April last year, after reports that two of the bishop’s lovers had physically fought over him.

There is any number of questionable things about religion—and the vow of celibacy is one of them. The vow does not make sense given the strong interest humans have in sex, which religious people call a gift from their God. 

It is not written anywhere in the Bible that God directed that Catholic priests should always be celibate. There is no evidence to suggest that celibate priests are more moral than priests who are free to have sex with any woman of their choice at a place and time of their choosing. 

Celibate priests or those who pretend to be celibate, at least in Uganda, have wreaked havoc on marriages by sleeping with married women. 

He wrote about priests “offering money for sex…and a fair number of priests’ and bishops’ children scattered around the nation, who are carefully hidden from view (and not so carefully!)”.

The church reacted angrily and threatened Fr Musaala with excommunication. But he did nothing wrong. The church needs to reform.


Sunday Thought cuts through the noise of prayer, piety, and superstition to ask the questions most people avoid. It examines God, faith, and religion—not to preach, but to probe, challenge, and sometimes unsettle. Whether you believe, doubt, or have stopped looking altogether, Sunday Thought will make you think, question, and maybe even rethink everything you thought you knew about the divine—and about life itself.